Friday, May 1, 2020

Quote of the Week...from Noreena Hertz

All of us show bias when it comes to what information we take in.  We typically focus on anything that agrees with the outcome we want.                       ...Noreena Hertz

Noreena Hertz is an English economist, whose main claim as far as I'm concerned is that she delivered the above totally spot-on quote.  There are different types of bias, and maybe someday I'll go into some of them.  The bias I'm focusing on today is the kind displayed in media...particularly on cable news channels like CNN, FoxNews, NewsMax and MSNBC as their programming and hosts tend to take one side or another in the bipolar constant political battles ruling our lives during these divisive times.  If you're on one side you probably don't see the bias that agrees with your worldview but quickly pick up on bias against it...Noreena Hertz clearly understands that principle.  I don't claim to have a complete grasp about bias on these channels, but I came up with some examples...don't think I'm picking on one outlet over the others: I see bias on all of them. I'm not talking here about the "opinion" shows but rather the segments purporting to be news journalism.  Here are some indicators of bias in news on these channels as I see it...

1) Selection of topics to favor one's own side and cast the other side in an unfavorable light.  Conversely, they don't want to bring up issues that make the leaders they support possibly look bad.  So what you often see is different channels factually discussing...all on their "news" shows...completely different issues: look for the agenda behind their topic decisions.

2) Twisting context of reported statements, either to promote or criticize.  As a prime example of this, I look at our president, a man who speaks his ongoing thoughts out impulsively and comes up with a lot of statements that can be taken different ways.  It's a balancing act dealing with people like this: you want to avoid both expanding his meaning into something he never intended and going through convolutions of logic trying to excuse his sloppiness.  But you get both biases depending on the channel.

3) Most guests prop up host's assumptions and views. Although I've seen notable exceptions, the tendency is for a host to stack up a bunch of different guests, often in multiple split-screens, most of whom either echo or expand upon the "favored" position being discussed.  Sometimes they'll get someone to sit in giving the "other" side's take, but they're still usually in the minority of guests present.

3) Softball questions to own side, "gotcha" questions to other side.  A subset of "gotcha" questioning is using the problematic device of hindsight...almost always used selectively against one side...to put a leader on the spot in an interview.  It's sometimes hard to know what will happen the next day, the world being essentially chaotic as it is, and many breaking news stories and issues before us are unprecedented.  We all live and act in real time, not the past...I'm more concerned about what leaders are doing now, given the information they now have...than what they did or did not do in the past when they did not have that information.  It's not biased to explain past events and the roles our leaders played in them, good or bad, but conducting interviews with the main aim of making the one being questioned squirm is inherently biased.

4) Biased body language.  The tendency for program hosts to "look" through the screen at the viewer with expressions intended to imply that "we" are all of the same political orientation.  Head nodding, throat clearing, expression of feigned shock...these are all evidence of bias.

5) Allowing guests supporting their own side to ramble on conjecturally without any reality check while continually interrupting those opposing it.  It's really interesting to watch when a host has a "supporting" guest, followed by one they oppose...and then watch the host's demeanor and conduct toward them drastically change.

6) Emphasizing personalities of leaders rather than their policies. It's easy to exalt your own guy as the epitome of a leader with a sterling character, intelligence and virtue while those on the other side are villains, people to personally ridicule or vilify.  But if you're doing this because of what side they're on, then you are being biased. A prime example of this is pointing out when a politician slurs his or her own words as a sign of mental impairment or intoxication but ignoring the same coming from someone on the "favored" side.

7) Mixing openly-opinionated shows on the channel's schedule lineup with standard news shows.  A viewer may tune in to a particular channel to watch the news, which if they're not alert may smoothly segue into a sharply opinionated show: if not careful they might treat the second as a regular news show, too.

8) Hosts refusing to admit up front their own personal biases and claiming to be completely fair and neutral.  I wonder sometimes whether they actually believe their own words in this regard after watching their biased conduct.

In listing the above I could have given specific examples from different channels...but I'm afraid that how you read them ultimately comes down to your own personal biases.  More likely than not, a FoxNews viewer will see my examples expressed on CNN or MSNBC while one of those channels' adherents probably defines FoxNews as bias defined.  I wish people could stick with their own political orientations while being discerning and honest about the way news is presented and discussed on TV and how they receive it as viewers.  But alas, I sadly think economist Hertz had it right with her quote...

No comments:

Post a Comment