Friday, February 12, 2010

Emmitt Smith Won't Make It In the NFL

It's early 1990 and star University of Florida running back Emmitt Smith has decided to forgo his senior year and enter the NFL draft. The talking head experts in the national sports media know better, though. Sure, Emmitt was a big star in college, but wait 'til he gets in there with the big boys. For they believe that Emmitt Smith will simply be too small to be able to compete on the same level as other professional players. So what happens?

Emmitt Smith is drafted by the Dallas Cowboys. And he is accorded his shot at an NFL career after all. Sure is nice of them to let little Emmitt try to play with them. So all he does over his career is to set the all-time career NFL rushing record, win three Super Bowls with his team, be the MVP in one of those games, win league MVP, win seasonal rushing titles, and be selected for the all-star Pro Bowl several times. Oh, and a few days ago he was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. A modest accomplishment for someone who was too "small" to play the game, wouldn't you say?

Now we come to another player who the big shot experts say hasn't a prayer for success in the NFL: Tim Tebow. All this UF Gator did throughout his football "career" in both high school and college was to learn, fit in, and ultimately excel beyond anyone's expectations within the systems that his coaches had designed. It wasn't Tebow's fault that Florida's offense isn't readily adaptable to standard NFL formations. But the way the geniuses on ESPN, Fox Sports, and Sporting News Radio would want you to believe, this is an insurmountable handicap to overcome. And I have heard some cite Tebow's mediocre performance in the Senior Bowl as their "proof".

The Senior Bowl was Tim Tebow's first try at a completely different type of offense than he was accustomed to. And even though he was recovering from strep throat, he completed 8 of 12 passes during his stint in the game. It was also clear during the game that the opposing team controlled the line of scrimmage when Tebow was in there, further hindering his efforts.

I don't know what will happen with Tim Tebow in the pros. I have heard that Jacksonville was interested in possibly drafting him, with the thought of using him in a wildcat formation and on short yardage plays. But I wonder if instead, as was the case with Emmitt Smith, it wouldn't be better for this talented player if he went to a more distant out-of-state team to develop his professional skills. And develop he is certain to do, in my opinion, given his past track record of adaptability, determination, and focus.

One other thing: I am sick and tired of media sports commentators acting like college football is nothing more than a farm system to train NFL prospects. UF's coach Urban Meyer has recently undergone some criticism because his "spread" offense does not help train his quarterbacks for professional careers. But he has won two national championships with his system. College football is complete unto itself and does not need the NFL, which it has predated for several decades and will probably outlast for several more. Very few college players make it to the NFL, with most having to pursue their own careers after college. With that in mind, I would suggest that, instead of worrying whether their players can play pro ball after college, coaches at these institutions need to focus on getting them educated, graduated, and placed in productive, meaningful careers.

Because not everyone can be an Emmitt Smith.

No comments:

Post a Comment